Showing posts with label Entrepreneurship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Entrepreneurship. Show all posts

Thursday, December 19, 2019

Systems of Survival

Jane Jacobs is better know by her book "The Death and Life of Great American Cities" but Systems of Survival is her masterpiece on morality. 

Different from her previous work Systems of Survival is written as a dialogue which is interesting in itself. Each character represent a different point of view and together they develop, through a series of socratic dialogues and research, a moral system that answers the initial quest of a systemic thinking about morality in practical working life. 

Jacobs calls these frameworks syndrome not as a type of illness but "it comes from the Greek, meaning 'things that run together'. We customarily use it to mean a group of symptoms that characterize a given condition." In other words these systems represent a whole set of precepts to address how people solve their living problems.

"My hypothesis is that we have two contradictory ways of getting a living; therefore we have two contradictory moral syndromes, one to suit each way and its derivatives."
"I've come to think of the two moral syndromes as survival systems, worked out by long experience of with trading, on the one hand, and taking on the other"
These syndromes are the Guardian and the Commercial

Moral Precepts
Guardian SyndromeCommercial Syndrome
  • Shun trading
  • Exert prowess
  • Be obedient and disciplined
  • Adhere to tradition
  • Respect hierarchy
  • Be loyal
  • Take vengeance
  • Deceive for the sake of the task
  • Make rich use of leisure
  • Be ostentatious
  • Dispense largesse
  • Be exclusive
  • Show fortitude
  • Be fatalistic
  • Treasure honor
  • Shun force
  • Compete
  • Be efficient
  • Be open to inventiveness and novelty
  • Use initiative and enterprise
  • Come to voluntary agreements
  • Respect contracts
  • Dissent for the sake of the task
  • Be industrious
  • Be thrifty
  • Invest for productive purposes
  • Collaborate easily with strangers and aliens
  • Promote comfort and convenience
  • Be optimistic
  • Be honest

For Jacobs both systems or syndromes are natural and needed. However they can be corrupted by crossing the boundaries that separate them. Through a historic analysis the characters uncover these two syndromes, how the corruption made them fail and how has societies kept them separated.  Historically, to keep the two syndromes confined and moral integrity, we either use a cast regime or a rational moral flexibility. The group lean for an imperfect moral flexibility over the cast system.
"If it is true we're the only creatures with two fundamentally different ways of getting a living, it follows that to be as fully human as we can be, we should all be capable of using our two syndromes well. They belong to all of us because we are human, no other reason." 
"Every normal person the world over is inherently capable of both trading and taking..... But knowing when it's appropriate to use the one or the other approach, trading or taking, and how to do it properly - those things are culturally learned, mostly by imitation and practice."
Jane Jacobs' conclusions of Systems of Survival is that "the guardian-commercial symbiosis that combats force, fraud, and unconscionable greed in commerce life - and simultaneously impels guardians to respect private plans, private property, and personal rights. ... Perhaps we have a useful definition of civilization: reasonably workable guardian-commercial symbiosis"

Friday, November 29, 2019

The Future of Humanity

Michio Kaku is a physicist better know as a popularizer of science after his multiple TV shows, digital media presence and nine books. The Future of Humanity is his latest work (2018) and is a futuristic effort placed way ahead in the future.

With such long time frame, Kaku can speculate anything, but he cleverly connects it with the ideas of the present. This is the main take away from the book.

On one side The Future of Humanity is about unthinkable dreams, on the other the challenges that the laws of physics impose. "there is one thing that even alien civilizations will have to obey, and that is the laws of physics." 

With these yes-but and what-if games Kaku takes the reader to the farthest spots in the universe while explaining why leaving Earth is not as easy as Hollywood makes it seem.

The starting point of The Future of Humanity is that our species "sooner or later will face global crises that threaten our very existence", and hence we have the incentives to migrate to outer worlds. Despite the hazards that we may face, Kaku consideres the drive to adventure and exploration part of the human nature. Is it? maybe not but we can't ignore that we don't need the whole species to agree. with just a few entrepreneurs (i.e. Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Richard Branson) suffice. How difficult interplanetary transportation really is? How soon will it occur? How can it be, physically or just pure information? It is almost impossible to speculate about these questions without entering into more philosophical questions like what is consciousness  "Consciousness, I claim, is the process of creating a model of yourself using multiple feedback loops—for example, in space, in society, or in time—in order to carry out a goal."

For Kaku the Future of Humanity depends on our own civilization evolution. Unless we reach at least a Type I Kardashev civilization level intergalactic travel is only a dream. A Type I civilization will require new organizational rules. Our current models are incapable of such challenges. Kaku concurs with Elon Musk when he said:
"Elon Musk has speculated that, as civilizations master advanced technology, they develop the power to destroy themselves and that the biggest threat facing a Type I civilization may be a self-inflicted one."
The Future of Humanity has an optimistic tone. The broad range of innovations in healthcare, communications, energy, etc. that we see today are the seeds of a future that is still only possible in the minds of these futurists and entrepreneurs. Are we going beyond the limite of how much resources we can dedicate to a single quest? Kaku doesn't answer key questions like who will coordinate the necessary efforts? A global government? Who will pay of it? Not even the ultrarich have enough, is tax-payers money involved? What about other day to day priorities like deseases, poverty, etc. Who is going and who is staying? Who is up to decide? Is it wise to spend huge amounts of resources and energy in these endeavors?

Is The Future of Humanity to please the masses or is it a book to take seriously? Time will tell. 

Wednesday, October 23, 2019

The Relationship Economy

The Relationship Economy is an interesting book, nonetheless a mix of Customer Service ideas and DiJulius Group advertising. 

DiJulius highlights the importance of customer relationship in all facets of business; customers, employees, leadership,  human interaction in general.

Some ideas worth highlighting are the importance of service as a true differentiation factor. Most vendors of any product or service meet pretty well the requirements of the market, hence what becomes the true loyalty driver is service. 
"Customer Loyalty is a result of the multiple micro-experiences a person has with a brand. It reflects the fact that not only is that business consistently brilliant a the basics, but also that it has taught all its employees to be present in the moment at each of its touch points." 

Another one is the FORD (Family, Occupation, Recreation, Dreams) technique as a tool to foster relationships.  "FORD represents people's hot buttons, what each individual cares about the most. FORD is what they are passionate about. It is the topics that make them light up."

A corollary of the FORD technique is accepting Kalina Silverman   invitation to skip the Small Talk for the Big Talk to connect with anyone. 

Some closing remarks worth sharing: "World-class service is not something you do or deliver; it is something that is in you, in all areas of your life".

Thursday, May 9, 2019

Exponential Organizations

In 1982 Tom Peters and Robert Waterman published In Search of Excellence, in 1994 Jim Collins and Jerry Porras published Built to Last, and in 2014 Salim Ismail, Mike Malone, Yuri van Geest came up with Exponential Organizations. What do these have in common? They are examples of what Jeff Sandefer call "Business Pornography". Or what Phil Rosenzweig in The Halo Effect calls Delusion of Rigorous Research.

Books that sold by the millions pleasing the ears of people looking for instant success stories.

Exponential Organizations (ExO) makes some good diagnostics of the differences in pace and dynamics in the market. However the book is about Unicorns a fact that the authors acknowledge "Most of Lee's unicorns score well above the ExO threshold score." 

A principle in finance is that the higher the risk the higher the returns, thus an ExO has very high returns because they have very high risks.The book misses the mark by oversimplifies the market, it doesn't say anything about the thousands who die trying to be unicorns, it has no recognition to elements of luck and opportunity. Somehow Ismail et. al. despise the old fashion business model of bootstrapping and hard-work is still valid.

In the end they come with the idea of an ExO mindset which should yield into a ExO company and X10 returns. Economically if this were true the market would be dominated by very few companies, all ExOs, or the market would be so huge that I doubt it would be sustainable. 

Near the end of the book Ismail et. al. quote economist Brian Arthur: "Complexity economics is a different way of thinking about the economy. It sees the economy not as a system in equilibrium but as one in motion, perpetually 'computing' itself - perpetually constructing itself anew. Where equilibrium economics emphasize order, determinacy, deduction and stasis, this new framework emphasizes contingency, indeterminacy, sense-making and openness to change. Until now, economics has been a noun-based rather than verb-based science." What Arthur call the old economics is what Economist like Pete Boetke call "Mainstream economics" that oversimplified an emergent process, in opposition to "Mainsteet economics" that has always been dynamic. Maybe the velocity has change but markets were never static. Therefore, Ismail's ideas are not that original, successful entrepreneurs and business-people have succeeded because they understood the dynamics of their time.

Wednesday, December 20, 2017

Courage to Grow

Courage to Grow is personally relevant because I'm part of the story. Laura Sandefer shares her experience along her husband, Jeff, in founding and moving Acton Academy from an idea to an international success. As she clearly discloses the book is not a how-to or a treatise of Educational theory. It is a beautiful personal story full of challenges, successes, discoveries and hard moments, but overall it is an inspiring story for those willing to do something to change how kids are educated and raise these days.

Laura shares how they decided not to sign their kids in a traditional school after attending a Montessori school. The Sandefer's dilemma echoes with our own of not accepting the fact that the only option was putting our kids in a traditional school. 

In opposition of the traditional approach of Education where results, grades, titles and degrees are what matter, the Sandefer's wondered "Can a vision of school rationally encounter the power of love and claim it?" and they didn't stop at the question and moved forward and made Acton Academy a reality.

Acton Academy was quickly recognized as an alternative to the traditional system. It's differentiation is "Our biggest point of separation is the upside-down power structure that pushes control and decision making to the children." Indeed what I value the most about Acton Academy is that children became responsible of their own Education and life. 

"A month after their visit, Juan had already found families (we were one of them) who would enroll their children. And with that Acton Academy Guatemala City began to take shape."

Acton Academy is an evolving community that has extended world-wide. It is not a simple franchise system but a sharing of values and principles that anchor a joined effort to improve the education of our kids.

Thanks to Jeff and Laura, Juanma and Analu for trusting the children and taking the lead.

Sunday, May 28, 2017

How to Be Everything

From "What do you want to be when you grow up?" to "What are you up to these days?"


Emilie Wapnick rose to fame after her TED talk "Why some of us don't have one true calling" that has almost 4M views. Emilie has devoted to help people who are "multipotentialites" or someone with many interests and creative pursuits. This book is an extension of her talk giving anecdotal support to what multipotentialites are, and what they do to be more effective in spite of their multiple interests and lack of consistency.


The book is a good intro for multipotentialites, a feel good, "Welcome to the tribe" (as the title of one the chapters) book. It provides some tools to assess if one is indeed a multipotentialite and its kind. Finally it offers some tools to improve effectiveness. However the books is somehow soft, in a way it is expected since the core idea of multipotentialites is that they don't follow social norms on how to live ones lives. Nonetheless, that lightness seems like a rationalization, an excuse to fail on delivering. Like it or not multipotentialites live in the real world where people expect results on time, on cost and on quality, no excuses.



Hope Wapnick work gets the attention in academic circles to become a research subject and thus future books and papers. Meanwhile you can find more about Wapnick and multipotentialites in her site Puttylike.com


Wednesday, March 29, 2017

Shoe Dog

Bill Gates recommended Phil Knight's book Shoe Dog in his 2015 annual blog. After reading Knight's story I can't but agree with Gates.

Shoe Dog is a very honest memoir of Knight and Nike (NYSE:NKE), full of business wisdom but also the challenges and setbacks. He didn't sugarcoated his story like many entrepreneurial books. Reading Shoe Dog is an emotional rollercoaster, from stories of adventure, success, failure, doubts, despair, sorrow, pride and joy.

Things I found amazing about Phil Knight:
  1. He prepared ahead for the adventure. From the very early pages he tells the story of how he wanted to travel around the world. With near $0 budget yet "I spent weeks, reading, planning, preparing for my trip." similar stories are prefaces to his first trip to Japan, to Taiwan and China. 
  2. He cared for his team, having hired very odd people at the beginning mainly trying to help them to his support for the athletes they sponsored.
  3. He recognized his business journey very honestly, from making money, to dominate the market to contribute to the human drama. "I redefined winning, expanded it beyond my original definition of not losing, of merely staying alive. That was no longer enough to sustain me, or my company. We wanted, as all great businesses do, to create, to contribute, and we dared to say so aloud."
  4. His almost devotion to his coach and cofounder, Bill Bowerman, as well as to other people who contribute to Nike success. Constantly not letting Bowerman behind, naming the buildings after supporters, his appreciation for Tiger Woods, etc. 
  5. His connection with his family could be omitted but it helps to appreciate Knight's humanity. The struggle between a growing business and his family, his regret for not having spend enough time with his kids, his apologies to his wife, Penny, for having to waited and waited, 

The book has some pearls of business wisdom too, not as a recipe but as a testimony.
  1. Cash management is crucial specially for a fast growing business.
  2. Plans have a short life, specially when conditions change.
  3. Tell people what you want and let them surprise you with their results
  4. When you believe in something being stubborn pays off, but if you have doubts trust your team.
  5. An IPO may be necessary but the timing is important.
For those interested in entrepreneurship this book is a must. 

An interesting conversation with HBR Ideacast.


Friday, February 17, 2017

Playborhood

Mike Lanza is a Silicon Valley entrepreneur with whom I identified, not because his professional career but his devotion to his children and family. Like me, and many parents, Mike was concerned by the few opportunities children have to freely play this days. 

Mike's story came to me after reading an article in the New York Times by Melanie Thernstrom. The story was interesting but had a feeling of critique that I couldn't understand. Mike is not a play expert but a father who is not sitting in his couch whining and waiting for the government to fix his problem, he honestly is trying to provide a safe and fun environment for his kids to play. It was a relief to read play experts like Tim Gill, Peter Gray or  Lenore Skenazy, appreciate what Lanza is doing. 

But Mike didn't stop at doing something for his kids, he wrote Playbordhood. He researched about other initiatives all over the US of people acting and not just complaining. People of different socioeconomic backgrounds, in different setting, with different approaches. His book is not only a collection of stories but a guide for those who want to do something; from selecting the right neighborhood, to creating attractions for kids, to building a community, and more. He lays out a plan on how to create a playborhood. He is not naive in pretending that this is a magic potion that will fix the problem, kids outgrow the attractions, there is fierce competition from electronics, other parents have their own fears and preferences, etc. His message can be summarized as don't give up and keep trying. 
"My approach has been to stay the course as long as the positive response outnumber positive responses outnumber the negative ones. When I do get a specific negative reaction, I try to accommodate whatever complaint the neighbor might have."
Some of the critiques to Mike's solution are that he is an affluent Silicon Valley entrepreneur and thus he can spend lots of money on his playground. Mike challenges this idea not only by recognizing other initiatives with fewer resources but invites people to put their money in their priorities.
"I hope readers of this book will re-evaluate the relative budgets for the inside and outside of their homes. When weather is OK, a great yard is far more important to kids than the inside of the house. Moreover, even in bad weather months, kids don't appreciate expensive decor at all..... Having a great home entertainment system inside the house is attractive for them, but they will benefit far more from a great yard"
One of the key concepts of Playborhood is they are right were children live. Other alternatives like playgrounds and city parks are places where kids can't go on their own at the time they please. Going to those places become a planned activity. People come from different locations making it hard to create a culture of play and a community. Playborhoods have their issues, Mike may have done things differently from suggested by experts but the big picture is that this is an idea to stimulate others to act and improve.


Monica and me visiting Mike's playborhood

Sunday, June 26, 2016

A Brief History of Entrepreneurship

Joe Carlen book is History the way I wish I had in school. Instead of the disconnected list of events "A brief history of entrepreneurship" is a dynamic summary of human history since the first civilizations in Mesopotamia until the next frontier out of our planet, from the eyes of entrepreneurs and those pushing out the boundaries of the then current world.
"The transformation from rural agrarian to urban commerce took place during the Uruk period of Sumerian history, an era that began about 3,500 years ago."
The narrative of the book allows the reader to identify the birth of institutions we take for granted today. From the division of labor, the non-zero sum trade, financial instruments to fund explorations, the early corporation and merchant societies, accounting control, fiat money, etc. 


The book is mainly descriptive and not normative about entrepreneurship but it is easy to identify historic patterns. Carlen's sources make the book credible and a good reference to understand the systemic differences of motives and results. In periods like the early Sumerians and Phoenicians dominated more by City-States that had high commercial interaction progress excelled. In contrast periods with strong centralized governments like Romans and Medieval times the entrepreneurial spirit was limited to cronyism and corruption. No wonder why in the first kind entrepreneurs and merchants were in high esteem, while in the later were the lowest of the classes.

Chapter 4, An Enterprising Faith, is quite interesting under the light of the current geopolitical events. It describes the emergence and advancement of the Arab world in the VII century. Unified under Muhammad the Arabs expansion covered the Middle East, North Africa/Spain and parts of Central Asia. Despite it was a military conquest it was driven by mercantile concerns. The Muslim world was a remarkable pollinator. It expanded and advanced Greek scientific knowledge, made mathematical contributions like algebra, expansion of use of writing paper from China, silk, cotton, wool textiles from different regions, or African Coffee.

The Brief history has a space for Sumerians, Phoenicians, Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, Arabs, Chinese, Mongols, Western Europeans and their Imperial expansion to America, Africa, India and Asia, and the Colonist. Before the Industrial Revolution most of the benefits of the entrepreneurial spirit were limited to the regions that were thriving and not globally. The last part starts with the Industrial Revolution. Carlen misses the role of ideas in the change of pace of progress, something that Deirdre McCloskey brilliantly explains. Nonetheless he points out:
"However, prior to the Industrial Revolution, innovation in the form of disciplined scientific inquiry rarely intersected directly with the world of entrepreneurship. The original Industrial Revolution, that is, the one that occurred in Britain and peaked during the seventy-year period of 1760-1830, is when those worlds coalesced in unprecedented ways."

Carlen covers the modern era with short biographies of business tycoons from Abraham Darby (1678-1717) to today pioneers of the last frontier like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos and Richard Branson. Including people like James Watt, Thomas Edison, the wrongly called Robber Barrons (check Andrew Bernstein's "The Capitalist Manifesto"), entrepreneurs in different parts of the world (China, Latin America, Africa, or Russia), the information revolution with Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and more.

Overall the "A Brief History of Entrepreneurship" is a good reference of how entrepreneurship and human progress go hand in hand. A window of the conditions that allow these ever present minds shine and make all our lives better.

My rating 4 stars.


Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Unleash Your Inner Company

As times turn harder more and more people are considering starting their own businesses, Unleash Your Inner Company is a timely contribution and a required read for those serious about it.

In Unleash your Inner Company the successful entrepreneur John Chisholm (@johndchisholm) shares his experience to all those who want to be entrepreneurs as well.

John's book is easy to read, fun to follow and provides very useful training. He lays out a 10 step process to think, organize and make your ideas coherent. Beginning from the more simple but fundamental question of what you love and what you are good for, up to creating a full strategy with pricing, differentiation, escalation, financials, etc. The road map works like a blueprint, to build from the ground up, from the basics to the complex. In addition to the framework itself, John takes the reader by the hand clarifying his ideas with examples (some from his personal experience, others are made up yet very concise), suggesting exercises to put the concepts into practice, and FAQ's sections that expand each step further. At the end of each step a short recap becomes a cheat sheet of lessons learned.

In addition to his model, John introduces basic but powerful economic concepts to the entrepreneur. Sort of a reality check for the entrepreneur to be aware of non-business related challenges. Among these ideas we find the importance of institutions to create the environment for ideas to flourish, the damaging effects of centrally controlled regulations on innovation, and the ethics of entrepreneurship as a value creating endeavor.

In the last sections of the book, John adds some useful tools such as 101 accounting, and the relationship of his 10-step model and the popular Business Model Canvas.

John explains that he took the challenge of writing this book after he presented at TEDxUFM in 2011. It is a satisfaction to see an idea materialize. Bellow is an interview given during his visit to Universidad Francisco Marroquin for the event.




My rating 5 stars

Friday, December 19, 2014

Zero to One

Peter Thiel's book has many valuable ideas for entrepreneurs, however two stood out to me. The concept of Zero to One in itself, and the defense of efficient monopolies. Zero to One is a challenge to the me too culture of entrepreneurship and society. While Entrepreneurship is becoming more and more a buzzword and more people want to be entrepreneurs, schools turn their programs to entrepreneurship, colleges and universities claim that they teach entrepreneurship, most of the initiatives are dull me too projects. In order to keep up growing the world needs more dare initiatives, the ones that are truly disruptive, the Zero to One's.

Tied to this is Thiel's defense of efficient monopolies. In order to be a Zero to One company entrepreneurs have to make outstanding differential products. Once they achieve these they can gain a monopoly because none can compete with them (not as a result of government protection). Thiel claims that in history great innovations were followed by monopolistic dominance in their markets. He doesn't mention the "Robber Barons" who earn bad press from government and inefficient competitors or the Sherman Act enacted to destroy them, but it is a time in history where the efficient monopoly got a bad reputation. Capitalism is about creation of wealth not redistribution, efficient monopolies create wealth, perfect competition is a zero sum game.

Thiel presents an invitation to entrepreneurs to dare to create truly different product, avoid the red blood competition game.

Some chapters of the book are a little hard to follow, probably because the book itself is an edited written version of lecture notes. Yet the book is worth reading and discussing to put the feet on the ground of entrepreneurs.

Sunday, December 14, 2014

The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers


This is one of the best Business books ever written. Most books speak of how to run businesses in a near perfect world (peace time). Some autobiographies are honest enough to recognize the struggle of the entrepreneur and not only the glory that made them famous. In The Hard Thing About Hard Things, Ben Horowitz does both things. His nerve wrecking story make you question yourself if you really want to be an entrepreneur or may be enchanted by the legends of the Mark Zuckerberg, the Steve Jobs, the Bill Gates, etc. Reading Ben story is like reading 100 Harvard Business Cases in 1 and making decisions without the information provided.

In the second part Ben presents a detail debrief of his experience. Unlike a classical business book à la Jim Collins, Ben's is not a prescription of how to run a business but a summary of what worked for him. However the underlying principles are applicable to many different settings.


The last part of the book is a short summary of a16z, their VC firm. More than the VC itself this part and the book exposes the need of Ben to share his experience and help founders succeed. 

If you are considering starting an entrepreneurship career The Hard Thing About Hard Things is a must read. 

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Only the Paranoid Survive

Andy Grove published Only the Paranoid Survive in 1996, a year before Clayton Christensen's "The Innovators Dilemma". Reading Grove is a description of what it meant to be inside an Strategic Inflection Point (Disruptions) and survive. His advice for entrepreneurs, managers, and professionals is as current as it was almost 20 years ago. 

Another gold mint in the book is Grove's vision of the future. Now that the future was revealed we can appreciate how Intel leadership prepare and succeed. 20 yrs ago lots of people didn't know what the internet was, the iPhone and the smartphone revolution occurred 10 yrs later and the internet of things is in the making. Yet Grove anticipated how this changes will affect the industry.

Finally Grove offers the same advice to individuals to manage their careers. Like Reid Hoffman's recent concept of "Permanent Beta", Grove anticipated the end of the life long employment and the need to look for "Career Inflection Points" adapting the same rules he followed in Intel

Saturday, April 12, 2014

The Capitalist and the Entrepreneur

Sometimes when I read entrepreneurial theories I wonder if academics speak to real entrepreneurs. Peter Klein book hit the nail in the head, from my personal experience in business. He explains the role of the entrepreneur and the markets, and why only a free system is fertile soil for entrepreneurial ventures to create real growth for society.

The Capitalist and the Entrepreneur is also relevant as it explains with great detail the principles and differences in the Austrian School of Economics. With plenty footnotes to guide the readers interest to deepen in this school of thought Klein discusses why Austrian ideas about the price theory, the role of capital allocation, etc. divert from mainstream economics that reduce the entrepreneur and the firm to an abstract black box. Using the ideas of the AE Klein portraits a dynamic and living organization with the entrepreneur, managers, people and resources.

Since the interest on entrepreneurship is on the rise, Klein's book should go hand in the promotion of these ideas.

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Monday, February 10, 2014

Madmen, Intellectuals, and Academic Scribblers:


Wayne Leighton and Ed Lopez present in Madmen, Intellectuals and Academic Scribblers an interesting interpretation of the dynamic of regulations. Beginning with a clear fast forward history of philosophy they set the ground to present their model. Overall the book builds on Public Choice ideas adding the perspective of the entrepreneur of ideas. Contrary to common belief that ideas change only through crisis and revolutions, Leighton and Lopez explain the role of the Entrepreneurs of Ideas. If institutions are sound there is no need to revolutions, just a dynamic that resembles the spontaneous order in a market of ideas.

Each one of the roles act at different levels in society affecting the probabilities of ideas to win in the market. Each actor adequate the message to a different audience from the one who generate the ideas to the people who vote for them in the democratic game.


The book left me thinking on what was behind the scenes of current policies and regulations, and what new ones are in the making.